Disputatio:Rolandus Koch

E Vicipaedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Dubitamus facta enim vel facinora hic descripta esse recta.

Orlandus[fontem recensere]

Shouldn't it be Orlandus?

From http://www.infobitte.de/free/lex/wpdeLex0/online/d/di/Di_Lasso-_Orlando.htm:

  • Italienisch: Orlando di Lasso
  • Französisch: Orlande/Roland de Lassus (übersetzt in etwa: »von dort oben«)
  • Lateinisch: Orlandus Lassus

--Roland2 22:28, 7 Iunii 2006 (UTC)

delenda, vide UV[fontem recensere]

UV, make your case here, who is this guy?--Ioshus Rocchio 04:24, 8 Iunii 2006 (UTC)

He is the prime minister (you might call him governor) of the State of Hessen in Germany. He was apparently involved in bad news headlines in the context of a money laundering scandal and he seems to be a somewhat controversial figure. Still, the plethora of insults contained in this article obviously do not comply with the requirement of a neutral point of view.
While, to me, at first reading the entire article seemed to be one huge insult, I agree with Roland that the first sentence is NPOV. What if we keep the first sentence and delete the rest? (sadly, because I really had to laugh when I read it, but in my view it does not fit in an encyclopedia)
Greetings, --UV 22:38, 8 Iunii 2006 (UTC)
Yeah, you're absoluely right. Stercorem delebo!--Ioshus Rocchio 03:08, 9 Iunii 2006 (UTC)
Gratias ago. --UV 22:31, 9 Iunii 2006 (UTC)

ratio pro contentorum delendo[fontem recensere]

{{delenda}}

hilarius sed POV. 
--UV 00:03, 7 Iunii 2006 (UTC)
At least the first sentence is ok.
--Roland2 22:15, 7 Iunii 2006 (UTC)
Delevi contenta quae NPOV disrupit, ob sententiam populorum.--Ioshus Rocchio 03:12, 9 Iunii 2006 (UTC)

I agree to delete the sections which are wrong or an insult. {{delenda}} is for deleting a whole article. See Vicipaedia:Deletio. --Roland2 06:05, 9 Iunii 2006 (UTC)

Right, Rol, I was just explaining why the article is now just one sentence.--Ioshus Rocchio 12:26, 9 Iunii 2006 (UTC)
I agree that {{delenda}} is just for deleting a whole article. At first sight, I failed to realize that the first sentence is NPOV. Greetings, --UV 22:31, 9 Iunii 2006 (UTC)

surname[fontem recensere]

don't you latinize the surname? there are many people in germany to this day where some ancestor latinized their surname a long time ago, like "Gropius", or "Sartorius". While i never worked at Vicipaedia before and thus don't know how it works, i would propose to move this article to Rolandus Coquus (or Orlandus Coquus, if the above editor has a point). --Sarefo 10:50, 30 Decembris 2007 (UTC)

Thanks for asking. I replied at Disputatio Usoris:Sarefo. Andrew Dalby (disputatio) 11:24, 30 Decembris 2007 (UTC)